
I’m usually not bothered by other people’s income, but the apostle Paul’s income has caused me great angst. The man who traveled extensively throughout the Roman world, preaching and teaching, also worked a day job. The man who wrote world-changing letters did so free of charge while earning money through manual labor. Why did Paul roll up his sleeves and get to work? What was he thinking? And why are so few ministers today following his example? 1
Did Paul Accept Financial Support from Churches?
Let’s begin with Paul’s question in 1 Corinthians 9: “If we have sown spiritual seed among you, is it too much if we reap a material harvest from you?” (v. 11 NIV). (Unless otherwise noted, all verses taken from NIV, 2011.) How should the Corinthians answer this question? The entire thrust of Paul’s argument leads to this response, “No, it is not too much for you to reap a material harvest from us.”
He continues by saying that those who serve in the temple eat the temple food and those who serve at the altar partake of the altar food. He then adds, “In the same way, the Lord has commanded that those who preach the gospel should receive their living from the gospel” (v. 14). So Paul’s arguments are based on the principle of reciprocity and a divine command—”the Lord has commanded.” What does “receive their living from the gospel” mean? Since Paul’s two examples mention food, it probably refers to daily meals. As he says a few verses earlier, “Don’t we have the right to food and drink?” (1 Cor. 9:4). When did the Lord give the command that preachers should receive their living from the gospel? This probably refers to Jesus’ command in the Gospel of Luke. Before he sent out his disciples in pairs to preach, he said,
When you enter a house, first say, “Peace to this house”. . . Stay there, eating and drinking whatever they give you, for the worker deserves his wages. (Lk. 10:5-7)
If this is the Lord’s command to which Paul refers, then “receive their living” or “earn their living” (HCSB) includes lodging, food, and drink. Additionally, Paul says “the one who receives instruction in the word should share all good things with their instructor” (Gal. 6:6) and “all good things” must include material support of various kinds. Teachers needed aid because they were giving up time when they could have been earning money at work. In keeping with this general principle, Paul accepted material support from the church he founded in Philippi, a city in northern Greece. He writes:
You Philippians know from the time of my first mission work in Macedonia how no church shared in supporting my ministry except you. You sent contributions repeatedly to take care of my needs even while I was in Thessalonica. . . I am full to overflowing because I received the gifts that you sent from Epaphroditus. Those gifts give off a fragrant aroma, an acceptable sacrifice that pleases God. (Phil. 4:15-18 CEB)
The Philippians’ concern for Paul went beyond a one-time donation: “You sent contributions repeatedly.” Even when he was about a four-days’ journey west in Thessalonica, they sent aid and Paul continued to accept. As a result of their repeated and unique support, Paul publicly acknowledges their generosity. What were the “gifts” the Philippians sent? It doesn’t say, but in keeping with what we have already seen, they probably included food items. Did they also give him money? We don’t know. At this point, we have arrived at a simple conclusion: Paul believed teachers or preachers have a right to receive material support from their listeners. This does not mean, however, that he ever demanded or coerced people to give to him nor did he specify how much should be given. It also does not mean that this support should be equated with a full-time salary. (More on this below.)
Why Paul Refused Payment from the Corinthians
But Paul made other comments which complicate that simple conclusion. Immediately after acknowledging his right to receive compensation from the Corinthians, who lived in southern Greece, he states,
But we did not use this right. On the contrary, we put up with anything rather than hinder the gospel of Christ. . .
But I have not used any of these rights. And I am not writing this in the hope that you will do such things for me . . . What then is my reward? Just this: that in preaching the gospel I may offer it free of charge, and so not make full use of my rights as a preacher of the gospel. (1 Cor. 9:12-18)
If Paul was not compensated from the Corinthians, how did he make it financially? After all, he stayed in Corinth for at least a year and a half and presumably he would have needed housing, food, and essential items. He also probably needed writing materials, which were not cheap. Here’s what he says in 2 Corinthians:
Was it a sin for me to lower myself in order to elevate you by preaching the gospel of God to you free of charge? I robbed other churches by receiving support from them so as to serve you. And when I was with you and needed something, I was not a burden to anyone, for the brothers who came from Macedonia supplied what I needed. I have kept myself from being a burden to you in any way, and will continue to do so. (11:7-9)
Although Paul uses hyperbole— “I robbed other churches”—the answer is clear: other churches provided for Paul so he could minister free of charge in Corinth. (Since Philippi was a city in Macedonia, “the brothers who came from Macedonia” may be another reference to Philippian believers.) This support enabled Paul to consistently refuse compensation from the Corinthians, allowing him to say:
- “I was not a burden to anyone”
- “I have kept myself from being a burden to you in any way”
Ironically, this noble practice appears to have hurt Paul’s reputation in Corinth. Listen closely to his question: “Was it a sin for me to lower myself in order to elevate you by preaching the gospel of God to you free of charge?” Someone was disparaging Paul because he preached “free of charge” so he feels the need to defend himself.
What Was Paul’s Day Job?
But Paul had another source of income, which he indicates in this way: “We work hard with our own hands” (1 Cor. 4:12) and “Is it only I and Barnabas who lack the right to not work for a living?” (9:6). What type of work was Paul doing? The book of Acts supplies this information:
After this, Paul left Athens and went to Corinth. There he met a Jew named Aquila, a native of Pontus, who had recently come from Italy with his wife Priscilla, because Claudius had ordered all Jews to leave Rome. Paul went to see them, and because he was a tentmaker as they were, he stayed and worked with them. (18:1-3)
Although Paul received aid from Macedonian believers that didn’t stop him from working a regular job. Paul, Aquila, and Priscilla were “tentmakers by trade.” The Greek word translated “tentmaker” can be used for any type of leather worker. How was this type of work perceived at the time? Douglas Campbell writes:
Handworkers were pretty unimportant in ancient society. They were badly educated, horribly poor, and had to work from dawn to dusk with their hands to eke out a living. The upper classes despised them because they were just one step above slaves and beggars. Anyone who had to work with their own hands for a living was a social nonentity, and no one with any class would do anything that was manual. (Pauline Dogmatics, Kindle 4858)
So Paul received gifts from certain churches and he performed difficult and degrading manual labor in Corinth. But is Corinth a singular example of his hardworking lifestyle? We must follow Paul to other cities to find out. We’re now ready to answer the key question: Why did Paul work a day job?
Reason 1: He did not want to obstruct the advance of the gospel.
Why was Paul so adamant about refusing payment in Corinth? He believed that accepting payment would “hinder” (NIV) or be an “obstacle” (ESV) to the gospel of Christ (1 Cor. 9:12). It was like he was looking down at a toy train set and asking, “How can I get this train to move faster?” then proceeded to remove everything that was slowing it down. How would accepting payment in Corinth obstruct the gospel? The answer is not explicitly stated so we can only speculate.
First, the believers in Corinth were deeply divided over their leaders with some claiming to follow Paul, others Apollos, others Cephas, and still others Christ (1 Cor. 1:12). Some suggest that by accepting payment from certain groups, Paul would have increased these divisions.
Second, in his subsequent letter, Paul writes, “Unlike so many, we do not peddle the word of God for profit” (2 Cor. 2:17). This is an intriguing yet frustratingly vague statement. What does it mean to “peddle the word of God for profit”? Were they changing it so that they would be financially rewarded? Or were they faithfully preaching the word while also demanding payment? Perhaps Paul’s statement a few verses later gives us a clue: “we have renounced secret and shameful ways; we do not use deception, nor do we distort the word of God. On the contrary, by setting forth the truth plainly we commend ourselves to everyone’s conscience in the sight of God” (4:2). If these words shed light on 2:17 then peddling the word of God for profit means distorting it for a financial reward. However we understand peddling the word, we know that “many” were preaching with the wrong motive—”for profit.” And Paul makes a distinction between his practice and their practice. In 2 Corinthians Paul mentions his competition, noting that some even call them “super-apostles” (2 Cor. 11:5). So how does Paul compete with them? How does he defend his credibility as an apostle? Here’s how his argument unfolds in 1 Corinthians 9:
- “This is my defense to those who sit in judgment on me” (v. 3).
- Workers, such as soldiers, farmers, and shepherds, have a right to be compensated (vv. 7-10).
- It was well within our rights to be compensated by you (Corinthians) for sowing spiritual seed among you (vv. 11-12).
- Those who serve in the temple (priests) are compensated in the temple (v. 13).
- “In the same way, the Lord has commanded that those who preach the gospel should receive their living from the gospel.” (v. 14)
Then Paul makes his point: “But I have not used any of these rights. And I am not writing this in the hope that you will do such things for me” (v. 15a). He continues by stating this point emphatically: “I would rather die than allow anyone to deprive me of this boast” (v. 15b). What is Paul saying? He is saying that he is a true apostle because he is more concerned with the advance of the gospel than with his own income. Like Jesus, he set aside his rights for the sake of others. And he is asking the Corinthians, “Who else has done this for you?” Additionally, by working daily Paul was not only removing obstacles, he was creating new pathways for the gospel. He was giving himself the opportunity to befriend fellow artisans, share the gospel with them, and create a professional network. And this professional network probably provided him with the necessary introductions to begin working in new cities (Campbell, Kindle 9198).
Reason 2: He wanted to enjoy the pleasure of preaching free of charge.
This post was originally called “Four Reasons . . .” because I had initially missed this idea: Paul reveled in preaching for free. It was his reward, payment, and pleasure. He says,
What then is my reward? Just this: that in preaching the gospel I may offer it free of charge, and so not make full use of my rights as a preacher of the gospel. (1 Cor. 9:18)
Initially I thought Paul meant that he was looking forward to his future reward from God because he preached without pay. But after checking several translations, I think it makes better sense to conclude that preaching for free was Paul’s reward.
So what is my pay? My pay is to tell the good news and not be paid for it! That is why I do not use my right to take pay for telling the good news. (1 Cor. 9:18 WE)
Reason 3: He did not want to be a financial burden to his immediate audience.
According to the book of Acts, after Paul preached in Philippi he traveled about 150 kilometers west to Thessalonica, where he preached in the synagogue with some success. According to Acts 17, “Some of the Jews were persuaded and joined Paul and Silas, as did a large number of God-fearing Greeks and quite a few prominent women” (v. 4). As a result of this success, Paul was targeted by a jealous mob and was forced to escape in the night. With the Thessalonian community still on his heart, he wrote two letters to them. In the first letter, he writes,
Surely you remember, brothers and sisters, our toil and hardship; we worked night and day in order not to be a burden to anyone while we preached the gospel of God to you. (1 Thess. 2:9)
Paul and his companions “worked night and day” in Thessalonica. Why? “In order not to be a burden to anyone.” Likewise, in 2 Thessalonians, he writes, “nor did we eat anyone’s food without paying for it . . . so that we would not be a burden to any of you” (3:8). As the context shows, Paul and his coworkers sought to avoid being a financial burden to those to whom they ministered. Paul didn’t enter new cities with a plan to rely on his ministry for material support. He entered new cities with a plan to work with his own hands. And those hands, which probably became calloused over time, enabled him to stand in line and buy food with his own hard-earned money.
But there’s another piece of information we shouldn’t overlook. As we have seen, in his letter to the Philippians, Paul acknowledges that he received aid from them when he was in Thessalonica: “You sent contributions repeatedly to take care of my needs even while I was in Thessalonica” (Phil. 4:16). Combining that information with the statement above shows that Paul operated in Thessalonica as he did in Corinth: he worked and he accepted assistance from another community of believers.
Reason 4: He wanted to serve as an example of diligence.
Paul’s statement in 2 Thessalonians gives us a fourth reason why he worked. He says,
For you yourselves know how you ought to follow our example. We were not idle when we were with you, nor did we eat anyone’s food without paying for it. On the contrary, we worked night and day, laboring and toiling so that we would not be a burden to any of you. We did this, not because we do not have the right to such help, but in order to offer ourselves as a model for you to imitate. (2 Thess. 3:7-9)
Paul assumes that the Thessalonian believers remembered him as the same man who stretched leather in the marketplace with sweat-soaked brow. And he wants them to imitate him and his companions: “you yourselves know how you ought to follow our example.” Certain things are caught rather than taught and Paul wants his audience to catch his work ethic. Why did Paul care so much about the Thessalonians’ work ethic? Because idleness was a pervasive problem in their city. He continues,
For even when we were with you, we gave you this rule: “The one who is unwilling to work shall not eat.” We hear that some among you are idle and disruptive. They are not busy; they are busybodies. Such people we command and urge in the Lord Jesus Christ to settle down and earn the food they eat. (2 Thess. 3:10-12)
The new community of believers could not flourish with idleness unchecked so Paul and his companions sought to thwart this problem with their teaching and example.
Reason 5: He wanted to provide for those in need.
After Paul’s 18-month stay in Corinth, he sailed to Ephesus (western Turkey), where he stayed for more than two years (Acts 19:8-10), working and teaching daily. In his farewell speech to the Ephesian church leaders, Paul declares,
You yourselves know that these hands of mine have supplied my own needs and the needs of my companions. In everything I did, I showed you that by this kind of hard work we must help the weak, remembering the words the Lord Jesus himself said: “It is more blessed to give than to receive.” (Acts 20:34-35)
According to this statement, Paul worked so that he could give. Paul’s gospel, the message of God’s sacrifice, was displayed in his lifestyle of sacrifice: “by working hard . . . we must help the weak.” This fifth reason is closely linked to the fourth because he wants his audience to imitate both his work ethic and his habit of giving: “I showed you that . . . we must help the weak.” And we should highlight that this particular audience was composed of church leaders. This declaration brings a third city into view—Corinth, Thessalonica, and now Ephesus. From the cities involved and the time spent in these cities, a pattern emerges: Paul’s mode of operation was to travel, enter new cities, preach, and work. 
Summary: 5 Reasons Paul Worked a Day Job
In summary, Paul acknowledges that he accepted support from the Philippians and “the brothers who came from Macedonia.” But receiving support did not cause him to retire from his day job. He was proud of his manual labor in Corinth, Thessalonica, and Ephesus because it:
- helped to advance the gospel,
- gave him the pleasure of preaching for free,
- prevented him from being a financial burden,
- allowed him to serve as an example of diligence, and
- empowered him to personally provide for those in need.
Applying Paul’s Example Today: Six Key Caveats
What does Paul’s approach mean for ministers today? Should we require ministers to work without remuneration? Should we encourage ministers to practice a trade?
First, Paul’s teaching and example show that he was not following a rule nor giving a rule. Paul’s practice varied: he accepted support from the Philippians but refused compensation from the Corinthians. On the one hand, he didn’t refuse all expressions of gratitude on the basis of a particular principle. He didn’t think there was something wrong with receiving from those who wanted to give. Therefore, if people want to give to those who are traveling and preaching, such people are free to accept. On the other hand, at times, Paul refused support. In a self-sacrificing act among the Corinthians, Paul says, “we did not use this right” (1 Cor. 9:12).
Before we attempt to turn this practice into a universal rule, however, we must carefully consider what Paul says about it. He actually acknowledges that his refusal to be compensated was unique. He asks, “Is it only I and Barnabas who lack the right to not work for a living” (v. 6)? And “If others have this right of support from you, shouldn’t we have it all the more?” (v. 12). Who are the “others” Paul is thinking about? He mentions “the other apostles and the Lord’s brothers and Cephas” in verse 5. So Paul and Barnabas were not following the model of these “others,” but Paul does not disparage them; he only makes a distinction between their approach and his approach. Let me add that Paul’s statement to the Ephesian church leaders in Acts 20 is a strong encouragement for them to earn their own living and provide for the weak:
You yourselves know that these hands of mine have supplied my own needs and the needs of my companions. In everything I did, I showed you that by this kind of hard work we must help the weak, remembering the words the Lord Jesus himself said: “It is more blessed to give than to receive.” (Acts 20:34-35)
However, this statement does not include a command to always refuse support when it is offered. Presumably, they wouldn’t need help if they follow Paul’s example and teaching, but due to a variety of reasons, there may be times when they do need assistance. In sum, the uniqueness of Paul’s support-refusing approach means that we shouldn’t elevate it to a universal rule, but since he draws attention to it with pride, neither should we ignore it.
Second, we should not pull out isolated statements without considering the broader context. In 1 Timothy 5, Jesus’ words “The worker deserves his wages” are quoted in this context:
The elders who direct the affairs of the church well are worthy of double honor, especially those whose work is preaching and teaching. For Scripture says, “Do not muzzle an ox while it is treading out the grain,” and “The worker deserves his wages.” (v. 18)
So the principle of wages is also applied to church elders or leaders, especially those who preach and teach. However, from everything else Paul said and did, he could not have been envisioning a group of clergy who rely solely on preaching and teaching for a living. The context of 1 Timothy and the setting of Paul’s speech in Acts 20 make this clear. In 1 Timothy he is writing to Timothy and encouraging him to stay in Ephesus. In Acts 20 he is addressing the church leaders in Ephesus and telling them to follow his example of hard work to support themselves and the weak.
So the same group of leaders that were “worthy of double honor” and “deserved” their “wages,” were expected to work hard and provide for others. Thus, the statement in 1 Timothy 5:18 should not lead us to think of a professional class of clergy who are paid a full-time salary with benefits. (I know this assumes that both Acts and 1 Timothy accurately represent Paul, which is controversial to some, but it still demonstrates the principle of considering the wider context.)
Third, Paul’s ministry and modern church-based ministry are not the same. Paul was the “apostle to the Gentiles,” which meant he traveled frequently and brought the gospel to new areas. Also, he did not have a family to support. Is that your situation? If not, pause and consider the differences before rushing to apply Paul’s approach. Moreover, we should keep in mind that some of the components of modern-day ministry did not exist in Paul’s time. For instance, followers of Jesus met in homes not church buildings. Since ancient homes could only accommodate a few people, perhaps 20-30 at most, Paul did not have to work with several hundred people at one time.
In addition, Paul was not expected to officiate at funerals and weddings, conduct counseling sessions, make decisions about the building and property, communicate with a board of directors, and preach every week. I am not saying that any of these things are wrong. I am simply observing that many modern-day ministries revolve around one person. And if that is what we want, that person will probably need to be compensated. The key question, then, is Do we want ministry to continue revolving around one person? Admittedly, some are serving in a similar capacity to Paul, such as missionaries who often do not receive remuneration from their immediate audience and rely on support from churches and individuals in other areas. And some even work daily at a regular job in their host country.
As a side note, many believe Christians should tithe or give ten percent of their income to the church. And that money is used for staff salaries, building expenses, and other needs. While Paul encourages believers to be generous, he never commands them to give a specific percentage. In fact, his arguments run contrary to a mandatory tithe.
Fourth, ancient and modern study of Scripture are not the same. In many ways, Bible study is more cumbersome and time-consuming for us than it was for Paul. Think of it: Paul was fluent in Hebrew and Greek, and he simply preached and wrote from his understanding of the Scriptures and from his understanding of God’s revelation to him. And since he lived in the ancient world, he didn’t need to study it. Instead of spending five years writing a dissertation on two verses in Galatians, he simply wrote the letter to Galatia perhaps in an hour or two.
Today, Bible scholars spend a lifetime studying ancient Hebrew and Greek, ancient manuscripts, the ancient world, and a two-millennia history of Bible interpretation in order to properly understand what Paul was saying before applying it to our 21st century world. Our study of the Bible involves climbing mountains that Paul never had to set eyes on. Consequently, if we want someone to understand the Bible in a scholarly way, they will probably need to receive formal training, which will require time and money. In the process, that person will be giving up an opportunity to learn other financially viable skills.
Fifth, receiving contributions and earning a salary are not the same. If someone sends you money once in a while, do you work for them? Of course not. Paul accepted occasional donations, but that is not the same as earning a salary with benefits. Salary is defined as “a fixed compensation periodically paid to a person for regular work or services” (dictionary.com). In other words, “a person performing this particular job will be paid this amount this often.” This arrangement is contractual: “if you do these activities, we will give you this amount of money.” But Paul was not in a contractual relationship with his churches. Further, note the general nature of the New Testament instructions: “deserves his wages” or lodging, food, and drink (Lk. 10). This means that we cannot use the New Testament to argue about specific details involved in modern-day salaries because it doesn’t give us enough information.
Sixth, Paul was not alone. This post is about Paul’s income, but he did not work solo. He acknowledges Barnabas in 1 Corinthians 9, he worked with Aquila and Priscilla in Acts 18, and he uses first-person plural pronouns in reference to Silas and Timothy in his Thessalonian letters. Remember that Paul had the support of friends and colleagues.
Six Ways Paul’s Work Ethic Challenges Ministers Today
With those caveats stated, I still have a nagging suspicion that Paul’s refusal to receive compensation and his example of hard work means something for today. Here are six ways Paul’s example challenges us.
First, we should prioritize the advance of the gospel. Paul’s priority was not himself. He was a servant of the gospel. “How will this affect the spread of the good news?” is a powerful filter through which to press our decisions. Look down at the train track and ask, “How can I get this train to move faster?”
Second, we should not be lazy. Paul was a hard worker. He labored daily in Corinth, Thessalonica, and Ephesus. And as we have seen, he had good reasons for doing so. Moreover, Paul encouraged others to follow his example of diligence. This may be an especially important point for those in full-time paid ministry. I have heard stories and seen firsthand how those in such positions can fall into the snare of slothfulness.
Third, we should not have a self-sufficient mentality. It’s easy for those who work hard to rely on themselves and think, “I can do it all by myself.” Others may cover up this self-centered pride with spiritual language, “I don’t need anyone to help me because God will provide for me.” But Paul avoids the pride of the self-sufficient person who is unwilling to receive from others and the pride of the “spiritual” person who only talks about God providing.
- In Corinth, he worked as a tentmaker (Acts 18:1-3), received help from Macedonian believers, and mentioned the aid he received (2 Cor. 11:8).
- In Thessalonica, he “worked night and day,” (1 Thess. 2:9), received support from the Philippian church, and wrote about it with gratitude (Phil. 4:15–16).
- In Romans 16 he acknowledged Phoebe for serving as his “benefactor,” or “sponsor,” or “patron” (v. 2) and Gaius for his hospitality (v. 23).
Paul made sure to mention the people who helped him. Why did he need so much help? Probably because he spent a considerable amount of time in prison—when he wrote Philippians he was imprisoned. And ancient prisons were not like modern ones with daily meals and bedding provided. Also, he was injured from being persecuted, he traveled frequently, and he may have missed time working to focus on preaching. From the account in Acts, it sounds like Paul temporarily stopped working as a tentmaker to devote himself to preaching: “Now when Silas and Timothy arrived from Macedonia, Paul became wholly absorbed with proclaiming the word, testifying to the Jews that Jesus was the Christ” (18:5 NET).
Fourth, we should not have an entitlement mentality. Paul’s example raises challenging questions for those in full-time paid ministry. For example:
- Am I serving primarily for the paycheck?
- Would I be willing to serve free of charge?
- Am I being a financial burden?
- How does receiving a paycheck impact the effectiveness of my ministry?
- How do I feel about earning money by using another skill while still fulfilling ministry work?
These kinds of questions undermine an entitlement mentality. Rather than thinking he should always be compensated for preaching and teaching, Paul believed there were times when he should refuse remuneration. And this wasn’t just a one-time event as in, “I’ll preach this one sermon without pay.” He lived and ministered in Corinth for more than a year and during that time he adamantly refused compensation. Another way to say this is that Christian leaders should not be serving primarily for the money. In fact, the qualifications for overseers include “not a lover of money” (1 Tim. 3:3) and for deacons, “not greedy for money” (1 Tim. 3:8 HCSB). These are important instructions because the connection between ministry and money can quickly become toxic. How should church leaders serve? Peter writes:
Just as shepherds watch over their sheep, you must watch over everyone God has placed in your care. Do it willingly in order to please God, and not simply because you think you must. Let it be something you want to do, instead of something you do merely to make money. (1 Pet. 5:2 CEV)
Fifth, we should not despise ordinary jobs or manual labor. The apostle Paul worked a regular job. Working with leather was not an extraordinary occupation. Paul wasn’t too spiritual to roll up his sleeves and work beside others. He wasn’t too spiritual to sell his products in the marketplace, interacting with all sorts of individuals. Moreover, the man who said “Do not be proud, but be willing to associate with people of low position” (Rom. 12:16) practiced what he preached. 2
Paul’s example encourages us to see regular jobs as sacred. Many today may be serving in a similar manner to Paul—working common occupations while reaching out to others free of charge. A few years ago, I met a custodian who used to serve as a senior pastor. After telling me that he was happy with what he was doing, I encouraged him to return to the pastorate. But who knows, maybe he was following Paul’s approach more closely as a custodian than as a senior pastor.
Sixth, we should not think there is a one-size-fits-all model for ministry. Paul’s example provides us with another option than the traditional Western route of going to Bible college or seminary then finding a full-time paid position in a church or ministry. And this non-traditional track is the only path available for those in poorer countries or countries where the Christian faith is officially rejected. But even for those on the traditional path, Paul’s career as a tentmaker encourages us to consider developing a financially viable skill outside of traditional “ministry” work.
Conclusion: Rethinking Ministry and Money
Paul’s example is the complete opposite of modern-day celebrity preachers, who, at least in America, are often multi-millionaires. Imagine that celebrity preacher entering town, doing menial work, and refusing money offered for speaking or teaching. Paul’s approach is impressive because it avoids the following pitfalls:
- misplaced priority on the speaker’s status and earnings rather than on the gospel
- laziness
- self-sufficiency (i.e., “I don’t need any help from others.”)
- entitlement (i.e., “I deserve this”)
- demeaning view of ordinary jobs and manual labor (i.e., “That type of work is beneath me.”)
- one-size fits all mentality (i.e., “This is the work of ministry and this is the only way to prepare for it.”)
I wonder how different things would be if Christian leaders had avoided the same dangers down through the centuries.3
For an updated and expanded version of this post see the book below.
- I am far from the first person to wrestle with this issue. Søren Kierkegaard (1813-1855) writes, “Most people think—at most—about what job they ought to apply for, while my fortune is to be deeply involved in a struggle, the battle of ideas, the question of principle about whether so-called Christian professional offices are appropriate in Christianity.” And “I’ve decided to call attention to the price of becoming a Christian, beginning here in Denmark, in such a way that the whole concept—State Church, official posts, salaries—is blown apart.” (See Carlisle’s Philosopher of the Heart.[↩]
- In a landmark study published in 1980 titled The Social Context of Paul’s Ministry: Tentmaking and Apostleship, Ronald F. Hock argues that Paul held disparaging views of physical work. Why else would Paul mention his manual labor so often? He must have felt that it was beneath him. Hock also uses demeaning views of labor expressed by ancient Greco-Roman writers to support his argument. This view of Paul, however, neglects the importance and goodness of work, which would have permeated his Jewish upbringing. Along these lines, E. P. Sanders comments, “the way in which Paul referred to using his own hands to work is revealing: the poor do not find working with their hands to be worthy of special remark. We suggested that, though he had learned a craft, he had probably been trained for ownership or management. He knew how to use a secretary, and he dictated his letters, as we see in Gal. 6:11, where he notes when he writes in his own hand, and Rom. 16:22, where his scribe sends his own greetings” (Paul: The Apostle’s Life, Letters, and Thought, 144). While the evidence does not allow us to conclude that Paul held disparaging views of manual labor, Sanders is probably right that Paul was trained for something more than physical work. Thus, Paul was working in ways that were unexpected for someone with his background. We should also add that Paul had a rhetorical purpose in highlighting his manual labor.[↩]
-
From the comments below it seems that many approach this topic from one of two assumptions—ministers should always be paid because full-time compensation is ordained by God or, more frequently, ministers should never be paid because that is unspiritual. Since I don’t believe Paul was seeking to follow or establish a rule on this matter, I reject both extremes. On the one hand, I have benefited greatly from full-time paid Bible professors and authors. In fact, I don’t believe I would have had the interest or knowledge to write this article without that training. On the other hand, I don’t believe there is biblical evidence to support full-time salaries for ministers or Bible teachers, but that doesn’t mean such compensation is wrong because there are many aspects of our modern world not found in Scripture.
Consequently, we must not settle for simple solutions, which is essentially what both extremes are doing. Rather than seeking to lay down a universal law, we must think carefully about Paul’s example and our specific contexts. For example, believers in a rural village in Africa are in a very different setting than believers in a modern American city so how each applies Paul’s example will be different. How we handle this issue depends in part on cultural perception—how will preachers who are paid be perceived in this setting? The goal should be to live in such a way that “no one will malign the word of God” (Titus 2:5). If I had to lay down principles for today, they would be something like this:
- Some believe they must only preach for free. That is between them and God and they do not need to be convinced otherwise.
- In some contexts, full-time paid Bible teachers are not understood or accepted. In those settings it is not a good idea to attempt to be a full-time paid Bible teacher.
- In settings where full-time paid Bible teachers/ministers are accepted, those teachers should not be earning more than a middle-class lifestyle. Why? Greed is a major problem so ministers should not give the appearance of living a greedy lifestyle (Eph. 5:5; 1 Thess. 2:5). And leaders who are motivated by greed are called false teachers (2 Pet. 2:3, 14).
- Following the status quo is easy. We need more people who are willing to wrestle with this issue in a variety of settings.[↩]

After graduating from Gordon-Conwell Theological Seminary, I served as a Bible and theology teacher in Asia and the U.S. I enjoy dark chocolate, basketball, and writing. Explore all of my books on Amazon.

Dolores,
Thanks for your comment. My understanding of this topic has been developing since I first wrote this post 11 years ago. I have recently revised this post again. I know it is a long article, but I encourage you to read it again, or at least reread the conclusion. A main point for me now is not whether or not a church pays someone a full-time salary (I don’t think the NT gives us enough data on that topic so we need to use wisdom), but what the church teaches about giving. See the quote from Russell Earl Kelly right before the conclusion. Kelly has written an important book on the subject of tithing.
P.S. I have recently changed my comment policy to only allow one comment per person per post. You are always welcome to send me an email if you want to continue communicating.
Tim,
Thanks for your comment. My understanding of this topic has been developing since I first wrote this post 11 years ago. I have recently revised this post again. My interaction with three key NT passages (two of which you mention in your comment)—-1 Corinthians 9:14, 1 Timothy 5:17-18, and Galatians 6:6–is now near the beginning of the post. For the reasons listed in the post, I don’t think your interpretation of the first two passages is correct. In particular, I think some sort of compensation or material benefits are involved in 1 Corinthians 9 and 1 Timothy 5. Galatians 6:6 is also especially clear on this issue: “the one who receives instruction in the word should share all good things with their instructor.” This does not mean that we can use Paul’s statements to support the idea of a full-time salary for pastors. I don’t think the NT gives us enough data on that topic, but the principle of giving to teachers is expressed. And this idea was carried on after the completion of the New Testament. (See the quotes from the Didache at the bottom of the post.) A primary issue for me now is what a church teaches about giving not how much they give to the pastor.
P.S. I have recently changed my comment policy to only allow one comment per person per post. You are always welcome to send me an email if you want to continue communicating.
1Timothy imho is not referring to payment and if someone truly believes this should be paying widows.
Corinthians does not refer to pastors but to traveling evangelists.
Galatians is not talking about the physical.
2 thessalonians seems to say one that does work does not eat and applies to ministers.
Giving in the New Testament is when a need arises where someone cannot work. It also teams preaching the gospel is not considered work.
Steve,
This is a very challenging topic. I’ve been trying to strike the right balance between the biblical data and the real world for a long time. I wish you were right about this because I would like to have a clear-cut answer, but I don’t think you are. As explained in the post, I don’t see how to exclude material benefits (Paul’s phrase is “material harvest”) from these passages. That doesn’t mean we can use them to support the idea of a full-time salary, but it does mean some type of material goods should be given to teachers. This corresponds with Jesus’ instructions in Luke 10 and Matthew 10, which is the basis for Paul’s argument in 1 Corinthians 9 and 1 Timothy 5. Also material benefits cannot be excluded from “all good things” in Galatians 6.
Regarding the titles of Christian workers, Paul refers to those who have “sown spiritual seed” or “those who preach the gospel” in 1 Corinthians 9. And he was carrying out these functions for eighteen months in Corinth. In 1 Timothy 5, he calls them, “elders . . . especially those whose work is preaching and teaching” and in Galatians 6, “instructor.” While there are no perfect equivalents between ancient and modern roles, we can easily recognize those who carry out these roles no matter what we call them.
Paul’s statement in 2 Thess 3:10: “The one who is unwilling to work shall not eat” does not exclude teachers from also receiving material aid from their listeners. Paul worked and he received material support.
In summary then listeners should give to Christian teachers but that doesn’t mean they are required to give a full-time salary. Churches must decide for themselves what to give and teachers are free to refuse material benefits.
Thanks for your comment. Feel free to email me if you want to continue the discussion.
Correct!
And the good old boys club doesn’t want pew sitters to know the truth about “What saith the Scriptures.” Paul, nor any of the other disciples ever instructed believers to go forth and construct buildings specifically for the purpose of gathering together for worship. Had Christians adhered to the Word of God and followed the numerous examples about gathering together we would have a house church on every street. Following the Biblical examples would negate any need to have a “salaried” staff.
The salaried crowd is simply following after a manmade tradition and they will fight to maintain their sacred cow.
I was a pastor and like other Bible College graduates, I followed the traditions. But I soon learned about the problems that come with owning a building. Eventually, I discovered it to be a hindrance in the lives of believers who just wanted to learn more about the Bible in a place where they could interact with others.
And when I began attending a house church I also saw there was no need for a hierarchy of leadership. So I asked the brothers and sisters to not introduce me as “Pastor Hall.”
When the traditional pastors, missionaries, and evangelists learned that I refused to take a salary and rejected the notion of using the title “Pastor,” well…they stopped inviting me to preach at their camp meetings, crusades, and conferences.
In a manner of speaking, I was excommunicated from the good old boys club.
By the grace of God I have been able to reach out to a greater number of people than I ever could have had I continued to follow after the traditions of men.
David,
Thanks for your comment. I would love to hear more of your story and what you are doing now. Feel free to send me an email.
Bill,
I appreciate your carefully worded comment, which shows nuance and a willingness to incorporate multiple streams of biblical data. If you had said “all churches are so corrupted” I would not have approved the comment. I’m glad that you included the reference to elders. Some objections to the traditional church are rooted in an issue with authority. Granted, some leaders have abused their authority leading to this distrust, but there’s no way of getting around the fact that the church started with Christ, then was led by the apostles in Jerusalem and Paul’s leadership in the Mediterranean world, and continued under the guidance of elders. From the very beginning, then, churches had an authority structure. I summarize the NT references to elders in this post.
I agree that some churches have an unhealthy focus on the senior pastor and greedy leaders are a problem in many organizations, including the church. I also agree that tithing is not taught in the New Testament, but believers are encouraged to give generously. And Paul said, “the one who receives instruction in the word should share all good things with their instructor” (Gal 6:6).
You may find what you are looking for in a house church. You can do an online search for house churches in your area. However, regarding your concern about one person being in control of the meeting, that can still occur in house gatherings, where no one is getting paid. Practically, someone must lead or chaos will likely ensue. Of course, leadership of the meeting can rotate to different people, but if no one is leading, What song should we sing? Who will pray? What will we discuss?
While some people are power hungry, I think structure is eventually brought into organizations for practical reasons. And we see structure set in place in Acts 14 with the elders Paul appointed and then clearly in 1 and 2 Timothy. Like you, though, I would like to see meetings more open to the congregation. Robert Banks has written a good book on this topic. However, keep in mind that the larger the church the more structure is required. A meeting with 200 people needs more structure than a meeting with 20 people. The church in Corinth was composed of small home gatherings so spontaneity was easier to incorporate.
I’m happy to continue the discussion through email if you want.
NIV, 2011 unless stated otherwise. Your quote is from KJV. The word “communicate” in KJV does not mean have a conversation. It means “share” as most English versions have. See the list here.